/archive/cosmetics/plugins/datapacks/ · last edited 21 Aug 2019 · Community
The incident involved a newly appointed moderator named Alex who misinterpreted a rule regarding in-game currency trading. Alex banned a player for life after receiving a report about an unauthorized trade, without checking the server logs or asking the reported player for their side of the story. This action violated our established protocol that requires evidence review before applying any permanent sanctions. The ban was applied within minutes of the report, showing a lack of due diligence and adherence to the escalation matrix.
The root cause was a combination of incomplete onboarding materials and Alex's eagerness to prove their worth to the team. The current guide does not clearly distinguish between minor infractions and severe violations, leaving too much room for subjective interpretation. Alex also did not complete the mandatory shadow shift where a senior moderator observes their first few decisions. This gap in training meant they acted on instinct rather than procedure, leading to the wrongful ban.
To address this, we have updated the moderator handbook to include a clear decision tree for common violations. The handbook now specifies that all permanent bans must be reviewed by at least two staff members before being finalized. We have also implemented a cooling-off period for new moderators where they can only issue warnings for the first two weeks. This change forces a slower, more deliberate approach to enforcement and reduces the risk of impulsive mistakes.
Going forward, every new moderator must complete a three-day observation period before being granted full enforcement powers. During this time, they will submit their proposed actions to a senior moderator for approval. We will also schedule a weekly check-in for the first month of service to discuss any difficult cases and reinforce the importance of community building over strict rule enforcement. This structured approach ensures that new volunteers understand the nuances of our community standards before they have the ability to make irreversible changes.