/archive/bots/trailers/creative/ · last edited 12 Oct 2020 · Moderation
The group discussed the current process for handling ban appeals and identified a need for greater consistency among moderators. It was agreed that all appeals should be reviewed by at least two moderators before any decision is made, ensuring that each case is evaluated fairly and without bias. A standard form for submitting an appeal was proposed, outlining the required information such as the reason for the appeal, the behavior in question, and any relevant context the player wishes to provide.
There was also a consensus that appeals should be handled within a reasonable timeframe—no more than seven days from the date of submission. This helps maintain trust within the community and ensures that players do not feel ignored or left in uncertainty. It was noted that some moderators had been using informal methods to assess appeals, and there was a clear push to document and standardize the process to avoid confusion and ensure all appeals are treated equally.
One open question remains about how to handle appeals that involve complex or unclear situations, such as disputes between players or ambiguous rule violations. The group agreed to revisit this topic in the next meeting and potentially create a more detailed guide for moderators to follow in such cases. Another point raised was the need for a clear communication channel for players to follow up on the status of their appeal, which was noted as an area requiring further development.